Apple Engineers invented a new way to make Spacer Fabrics Aesthetically Appealing for HomePod
Apple sued over the 'Memoji' Trademark that was granted to another Company last week by the U.S. Patent & Trademark Office

A Finnish Patent Troll Sues Apple Claiming that iMessage and FaceTime infringe 8 of their (Acquired) Patents

17.3 Patent Infringemeent


While a patent troll in Finland suing Apple for patent infringement goes by the name of MPH Technologies OY today, they were once called "Mobility Patent Holdings Oy." So why are they considered a patent troll? While the U.S. Patent Office has MPH Technologies listed as the inventor of patent 8,346,949, a simple backwards check using USPTO's PAIR system (or, "Patent Application Information Retrieval" system) shows us that the patent was not originally owned by MPH but rather Intra Secure Networks OY who filed the patent in Europe back in 2003 under WO2003063443 as shown in the screenshot below from the World Intellectual Property Organization.


2 X22 - patent by Intrasecure Networks OY

MPH Technologies is not listed on the original patent. They aren't the inventors. They simply changed the patent ownership to be seen on U.S. patents as though they were the originating company behind the invention. They were not. They simply acquired/paid for the patent. That's what Patent Trolls do. They acquire patents for the sole purpose of suing rich companies like Apple looking for a big pay day.


The list of patents that are listed in the MPH Technologies lawsuit include the following: 8,346,949, 9,762,397, 9,712,494, 9,712,502, 9,838,362, 7,620,810, 7,937,581 and 8,037,302.


We showed you how the first patent was originally an Intra Secure Network patent and the last '302 patent listed above is as well. The original Intra Secure Network patent for that could be found here. The pattern of deception is clear. 


Apple knew that MPH Technologies was a patent troll explaining why they refused to deal with them when MPH demanded Apple pay them a licensing fee (pay them a ransom) for their (acquired) patents. MPH Technologies is claiming that Apple is infringing their acquired patents in products such as iMessage and FaceTime.


To learn more about this patent infringement case, review the full court filing below in a SCRIBD document provided to you courtesy of Patently Apple.  


Mph Technologies Oy vs Apple Patent Infringement by Jack Purcher on Scribd


The patent infringement case presented in today's report was filed yesterday afternoon in the California Northern District Court. No Judge has been assigned this case at this time.


10.4 - Patently LegalNotice: Patently Apple presents only a brief summary of certain legal cases/ lawsuits which are part of the public record for journalistic news purposes. Readers are cautioned that Patently Apple does not offer an opinion on the merit of the case and strictly presents the allegations made in said legal cases / lawsuits. A lawyer should be consulted for any further details or analysis. About Making Comments on this Site: Patently Apple reserves the right to post, dismiss or edit comments. Those using abusive language or negative behavior will result in being blacklisted on Disqus.


The comments to this entry are closed.