Stats Show that e-Books are Still a Tough Sell in North America
Apple Reveals New Two-Way "Airplay" Interactivity & Hints of TV

Apple Finds "Proof of Infringement" in Samsung's Source Code

1AA - Cover - Apple finds proof of infringement in Samsung's Source Code

Apple informed the court last week that it intended to amend its infringement contentions in the second California patent litigation with Samsung to target the latest Galaxy S4. Yesterday, Apple followed through on their intentions and filed its motion against Samsung Electronics (Korea), Samsung Electronics (America) and Samsung Telecommunications America with the court in San Jose California. Apple's motion lists a series of specific patents allegedly infringed by Samsung's S4 as well as two patents allegedly infringed by Google's software known as "Google Now." Apple's document makes mention that they scoured through Samsung's source code and found "proof of infringement."

Getting to the heart of the matter, Apple's court document states that "Since the Court entered Apple's last amendment of its Disclosure of Asserted Claims & Infringement Contentions ("Infringement Contentions") on January 16, 2013, (1) Samsung released a new phone – the Galaxy S4, (2) Samsung and third-party Google produced volumes of confidential source code, (3) Samsung served interrogatory answers that matched source code to accused products, and (4) the Federal Circuit issued its mandate that altered this Court's preliminary injunction claim construction covering two of Apple's asserted patents – U.S. Patents 8,086,604 ("the '604 patent") and 6,847,959,"("the '959 patent") which are both titled "Universal interface for retrieval of information in a computer system"


As such, Apple moves for leave to amend its Infringement Contentions to include the Galaxy S4, add citations to confidential source code to the previously served claim charts, and to conform its contentions to the Federal Circuit's claim construction. Good cause exists for these amendments; Apple has acted diligently in its investigation, and Samsung suffers no prejudice by the requested amendments.


A Few Highlighted Quotes from Apple's Filing


On page 9 of Apple's latest filing with the court they state that "Based on its source code analysis, Apple has been able to consolidate its previously produced charts to reflect the significant overlap in relevant functionality across Samsung's accused products. The consolidated charts demonstrate that, as indicated from publicly available versions of the accused source code, the proof of infringement related to the accused functionalities overlaps substantially across operating systems and carriers. Thus, the consolidated charts reduce the overall volume of contentions without altering their substance.


Apple further states on page 10 that "On March 14, 2013, at Radio City Music Hall in New York City, Samsung announced its newest flagship product, the Galaxy S4." On April 27, 2013, "Apple obtained the Galaxy S4 and immediately began its infringement analysis, including Samsung's customizations of the Android Jelly Bean platform, covering the eight asserted patents." According to Apple, "analysis revealed that the Galaxy S4 infringes five of Apple's asserted patents. Indeed, Apple has determined that the Galaxy S4 infringes one or more of the asserted claims of the '502, '647, '959, '414, and '604 patents. As Samsung released the Galaxy S4 on additional carriers (Sprint and T-Mobile) in the first half of May 2013, Apple continued its analysis and confirmed the same instances of infringement.4 Apple promptly served infringement charts on Samsung that reflect its analysis of the purchased phones and demonstrate that the Galaxy S4 infringes in the same way as Samsung's other products."


Apple complains in their filing that "Apple's review of Samsung's source code was continually hampered by both technical issues caused by Samsung and by its failure to make relevant source code available."


For some clarity of Apple's latest filing, FOSS Patents points out that the context of Samsung's infringement in one instance relates to Siri. Specifically, the software known as "Google Now" and Google's voice activated search assistant, have allegedly infringed on Apple's noted patents.


In their conclusion Apple respectfully requests the court to grant their Motion for Leave to amend its Disclosure of Asserted Claims & Infringement Contentions. To review the entire formal filing, see the document provided below.


13-05-21 Apple Motion to Amend Infringement Contentions




PA - Bar - Notice

Patently Apple presents only a brief summary of certain legal cases/ lawsuits which are part of the public record for journalistic purposes. Readers are cautioned that Patently Apple does not offer a legal opinion on the merit of the case and strictly presents the allegations made in said legal cases / lawsuits. A lawyer should be consulted for any further details or analysis. About Comments: Patently Apple reserves the right to post, dismiss or edit comments. On most legal cases, comments will be closed.


The comments to this entry are closed.