Apple Prepares to Rock the Market with Hardware Subsidizing Program
The US Patent & Trademark Office published a patent application from Apple today that reveals various concepts behind a newly advanced service in development that entails subsidizing an incredible array of hardware from Apple. The hardware ranges from their sizzling hot iPhone to Apple TV - the set top box - to an actual television, notebook, iPod touch and more. The subsidization could also cover software from Apple or third party developers. What's the catch? You'll have to endure a very complicated and savvy advertising scheme that makes sure that you're paying attention. If not, the system can freeze the user out until compliance is met. This isn't for everyone, especially if ads in your face are something you want to avoid at all costs. But for the mass market, this is a whole new ballgame! Steve Jobs is noted in Apple's credits for this patent and we could be assured that his name all but tells us that this program isn't a fantasy of an Apple engineer. The implications of such a marketing move could rock the industry.
Advertising Architecture
Apple's patent FIG. 1 noted above is that of a block diagram of an exemplary architecture 100 (e.g., a hardware architecture) for presenting advertisements. An advertisement is defined as being one of the following: a commercial, some form of marketing information or a product/service announcement.
In exchange for allowing ads to run on your system, you may be able to receive a free operating system, OS upgrade, a new computer program or upgrade or even hardware could be free or heavily subsidized so long as you'll agree to view or listen to commercials.
So what kind of hardware are we talking about here? Well, Apple actually lists quite the range of possible candidates including portable and desktop computers, a network computer (NC), servers, electronics, iPods, game devices, mobile phones, wireless devices, email devices, personal digital assistants (Think iPod touch), embedded devices, televisions, set top boxes (Think Apple TV), etc.
Realistically however, I think that Apple would likely ease into this concept with perhaps a Mac mini and a lower end iPhone in 2010/2011. Another guess would be to subsidize a media tablet where magazine ads are a must. In 1984, Apple cleverly devised the "Take Macintosh out for a test drive" campaign to get people to try out this revolutionary computer. The subsidy concept is a modern day twist on that concept as a means of getting a lower end Apple product into more people's hands.
Advertising Enforcement
In implementations where the operating system or OPS-based advertising is provided using executable code in the system, it can be necessary or desirable to protect that code from being removed, rendered inoperative, bypassed or manipulated. As another example, the system can provide constant or repeated monitoring of whether the system presents the advertisement(s) as scheduled. If non-presentation is detected, the system can invoke one or more enforcement routines to seek compliance with the advertisement presentation schedule. Such enforcement routines can include, but are not limited to, disabling the system in whole or in part, reporting the issue to a responsible party, invoking an alternative way of presenting the advertisement (such as by audio when visual presentation is impeded), or by registering the non-compliance in a log that can later be used in a follow-up process.
In other words, Apple is going to ensure advertisers that there'll be no way for users to get around playing their ads. In addition, Apple can further determine whether a user pays attention to the advertisement. The determination can include performing, while the advertisement is presented, an operation that urges the user to respond; and detecting whether the user responds to the performed operation. If the response is inappropriate or nonexistent, the system will go into lock down mode in some form or other until the user complies. In the case of an iPod, the sound could be disconnected rendering it useless until compliance is met. For the iPhone, no calls will be able to be made or received.
In the case of a desktop or notebook, the UI and its components (e.g., menu bars, icons, etc.) may be faded, darkened, brightened, blurred, distorted or otherwise visually modified during the initial state (or while the advertisement is being presented) so as to emphasize that the desktop UI is temporarily inactive.
Subsidization: Managing and Presentation Architecture
Apple's patent FIG. 2 is a block diagram of an example of a system for the management and presentation of advertisements (200). The system includes a computer device 205 that is connected to an advertising management system 210 and an advertiser's system 215 through the network 108. Generally, the advertising management system distributes advertisements relating to goods or services for one or more vendors that operate the advertisement system, and the computer device presents advertisements 220 for the products, goods, and/or services being promoted by the advertiser's system.
The advertising management system can provide some or all of the advertising content 265 to the advertising presentation module 245. The advertising management system can also receive reports stored in the log 270 about activity on the computer device 205, to confirm whether the advertising content has been presented, optionally along with any other information that may be recorded therein. The advertising management system may also deliver additional information to the advertising presentation module that configures the operating system 230 to perform the presentation and temporary disablement steps at predefined times. Such additional information and other possible updates associated with the functions performed by the advertising presentation module may be transferred or downloaded to the computer device via the network on a scheduled or random basis.
The process of presenting the advertising content and receiving reports about information from the log may be used as part of an approach for subsidizing the cost of hardware and/or software for the computer device.
Target Marketing
The advertising assignments, noted in FIG. 2 as feature 280, defines what advertising content is to be delivered to what particular computer device and/or to which users, and/or defines when the advertisements should be shown, to name some examples. The advertising assignments may be based upon the computer device's capabilities; for example, high-resolution forms of the advertising content may be assigned to desktop computers, reduced-bandwidth content may be assigned to laptop computers, low-resolution content may be assigned to the iPod touch and video iPods, and audio-only content may be assigned to audio-only media players such as the iPod Shuffle.
The assignments may be based upon users' preferences; for example, a user may have filled out a questionnaire where he or she may have expressed a special interest in travel, and therefore may receive a greater proportion of travel related advertisements. In another example, the advertising content may be assigned based upon users' demographic information; for example, an advertiser for sports equipment may choose to market snowboards to younger users and golf clubs to older users. In another example, the advertising content may be assigned based upon users' geographic location; for example a regional chain of restaurants may choose to advertise only to users who live in that same region.
The advertisement system's usage tracking feature, noted as feature 285, monitors the reports that are returned from the computer device, and can use this information to tailor the assignments of advertisements. For example, the usage tracking feature may detect that a particular user clicks through a high percentage of ads for automobiles, and can respond by delivering to that user a greater ratio of advertising content for automobiles or auto accessories.
Enabling/Disabling System
Apple's patent FIG. 3 is a flow chart that illustrates an exemplary method of operations (300). For example, the operations can be performed on the computer device of FIG. 2. These operations relate to the presentation of advertising content and the enabling/disabling of a function in the operating system.
In some implementations where the computer device is an iPhone or iPod, the user may be prompted to press a certain button or keypad key in order to confirm that they are paying attention to the ads being presented. In one implementation, the approaches for verifying user presence can be made progressively more aggressive if the user has failed a previous test. For example, after the user fails the test the first time, the subsequent tests can be made to appear more frequently or at varying times. As another example, the test(s) can be made more subtle so as to render them more difficult to perceive, such as by reducing the size of a message box on the screen, or by making an audio prompt more similar to the advertisement in which it is inserted. If the user fails the test in step 314 the method 300 can perform step 310 over again; that is, the entire advertisement can be played again while the operating system maintains the function(s) in a disabled state.
In step 308, it is determined whether the user takes an extension. The user has the option to delay the presentation of advertisement content by using the available time extensions. For example, in a desktop computer, the user can select one of the controls 215 to choose to watch the advertisement content immediately, or to delay the presentation by using the available time extensions.
At step 312, the user has chosen to use a time extension and extra time is granted. In implementations of the method 300 where the user is allowed to accrue time extension credits, this step may also deduct credits from the users' total amount of accrued time extension credits. The method 300 then proceeds to repeat step 304.
Buy Time and Opt out of Ads Option
In FIG. 2 above, you'll note step 320. In this step, it is determined whether the user chooses to pre-buy usage time. For example, the user may volunteer to watch the presentation of additional advertising content in order to accrue time extension credits. In another example, the user may have an option to pay a fee in exchange for the temporary or permanent advertisement-free use of the computer device. If the user chooses to pre-buy time, then the extra time is granted at step 312. Otherwise, if the user opts not to pre-buy time, then the method repeats at step 304.
Apple credits CEO Steven Jobs, Freddy Anzures, Mike Matas, Gregory Christie and Patrick Coffman for patent application 20090265214, originally filed in April 2008.
Apple's patent FIGS. 4A through 4-D noted in the introduction depict exemplary screen shots of presenting advertisements in a user interface.
Notice: Patently Apple presents only a brief summary of patents with associated graphic(s) for journalistic news purposes as each such patent application and/or grant is revealed by the U.S. Patent & Trade Office. Readers are cautioned that the full text of any patent application and/or grant should be read in its entirety for further details. For additional information on any patent reviewed here today, simply feed the individual patent number noted above into this search engine. To read this report in another major language, use Yahoo! Babel Fish.
Isn't ad subsidized notebook was boasted by somebody few years ago.
Posted by: bonelyfish | October 22, 2009 at 09:43 PM
As a long time Apple user "Webomatica" why would a subsidized OS, which you wouldn't use nor have to, make you switch to Windows? If this doesn't apply to you, what's the problem?
Posted by: Jack Purcher | October 22, 2009 at 04:38 PM
As a long time Apple user, I always wondered what exactly Apple could do to get me to switch to Windows. Well, this is pretty much it.
Posted by: Webomatica | October 22, 2009 at 04:33 PM
With the future of some publishing media in doubt, and an Apple tablet computer rumored, I can see advertisements subsidizing a subscription to or purchase of digital content. The hardware subsidy is hard to predict success; but this system would yield higher advertising revenue as it's targeted and monitored. Think of Apple's user profile along with their personal interests revealed dynamically. This would lessen the quantity of ads needed for a digital subscription or book purchase.
Posted by: Robert B | October 22, 2009 at 04:27 PM
Macuser's report is sooooo lame. They come in late in the day and just go with the crowd of sheep. Baaaaad. Steve Jobs puts his name on patents like the ipod and iphone. So I think it matters when "the man" wants his name on something, even if the macuser writer doesn't think so. I'll trust Steve Jobs over Macuser's writer any day.
Posted by: Mark | October 22, 2009 at 04:19 PM
hmmm echoes the old days of e-machines ad supported dialup email too..
bad taste in my mouth.
Posted by: vuong | October 22, 2009 at 02:39 PM
Apple is warning Google. You wanna be in my face, I'll get in yours. How do you like them Apple's. Pardon the pun.
Posted by: Jimmy | October 22, 2009 at 12:22 PM
We have all been using ad-supported media (radio, TV) since the day we were born, so what's the big deal? They have found a way to keep the MadMen busy into the future!
Posted by: dijonaise | October 22, 2009 at 11:37 AM
This doesn't seem like something Steve Jobs would do. If this really becomes reality, Apple's going to turn into a HUGE advertising company, which totally doesn't seem like their kind of thing.
Posted by: JackieHuynh | October 22, 2009 at 11:27 AM
This sounds fantastic if it's opt-out, as users can try before they buy, sampling, for instance, a monthly ad-subsidized periodical before purchasing a subscription, and when purchasing, they can elect to pay full-price or a lesser price-plus-ads.
Posted by: John Blackburn | October 22, 2009 at 10:33 AM
I can see Apple doing using this as per Bill Garrett's comment, but in addition, this might be the way to have ad supported movies, TV, music etc. where Apple gets the revenue stream. It will not be obnoxious in your face advertising.. not with Steve Jobs name on it anyway.
Posted by: artMonster | October 22, 2009 at 10:31 AM
I don't think Apple would devise a system to completely discourage a newbie. That's not the purpose of such a proposal and Apple isn't Dell or some other schmuck company. Apple will ensure that you do have to look at an ad, maybe once in a while go to a website to look at something. So what. Apple will do it with class like they do everything. Well almost everything. I hate ads. But I also don't pay $1.99 to buy TV shows from iTunes when I could PVR it and get the show for free. Apple will make a kid or granny (as Donny said), happy to get a hold of a Mac mini (or whatever) or a low end iPhone instead of an Android phone. In China, India, the Middle East etc they'll eat it up. You're only thinking of parts of North America. There's a world out there that will jump on this with a big THANK YOU APPLE.
Posted by: Teri | October 22, 2009 at 10:27 AM
I find that pop up ads in web pages are enough to make me turn off the computer and find something else to do.this would cause me to deposit said device in the round file.
Posted by: Anon O mouse | October 22, 2009 at 10:12 AM
And, corrected already, with a nice emailed note of thanks. Well played.
Posted by: Big Al | October 22, 2009 at 10:06 AM
"...no way for users to get around not playing their ads."
So the user has to NOT play their ads? Perhaps it should read "...no way for users to get around playing their ads." Sorta like people who say, "I miss not seeing them anymore."
Posted by: Big Al | October 22, 2009 at 09:55 AM
I'm fascinated by these comments ("disgusting!"). What exactly is disgusting about it?
Let's see (for those who are so myopic, they don't get it): I can buy a MacBook Air for $500. I take it home, set it up, and am presented with two choices: 1. Go through the set-up process for the ad software and watch ads every so often in order to continue to use my MBA; or 2. Pay additional $800 and the ad software is automatically purged from the system.
If you want to buy at full price, you will never see an ad. For those people who could never afford Apple hardware before, this will be an exciting option. One could, for example, watch ad after ad while waiting in line at the DMV, or on a bus, thereby earning a lot of free usage time for later.
This is the most effective and efficient way of connecting manufacturers (and service providers) with consumers.
Posted by: Predrag | October 22, 2009 at 09:54 AM
Ha! Apple doesn't have to run the ads themselves. Just own the patent so Apple gets a cut whenever Dell, etc. decide to run ads on their own low-end stuff.
Revenge is sweet.
Posted by: Bill Garrett | October 22, 2009 at 09:45 AM
What's to be disgusted with? If you don't want it, don't buy into it. I like high end Macs so this means nothing to me. So what if Apple reaches down to challenge Dell? I say all the bloody power to them! Go for it Apple.
Posted by: Mark | October 22, 2009 at 09:25 AM
While it's not for me, I think that subsidizing a low end Mac mini is no harm to me if it helps students and grandmas to try out a mac. What's the harm here? Apple doesn't have to be a snob to be "cool." Great idea guys!
Posted by: Donny | October 22, 2009 at 09:18 AM
Don't want it, won't buy any of this goofy idea.
What is apple thinking?
Posted by: [email protected] | October 22, 2009 at 09:09 AM