Apple Files for MacBook Pro Trademark with Huge Twists
Apple Wins iPhone Patent for Missed Phone Call Management

Apple's new iPad with LTE is accused of Infringing 4G Patents

1 - Adaptix v. Apple
ADAPTIX Inc., of Dallas Texas is an award-winning technology company long recognized in the industry as one of the first developers of cutting edge OFDMA-based mobile wireless systems. The company claims to have conceived, built, and patented critical equipment and network features that form the foundation of today's advanced 4G broadband wireless technology and systems. Late Friday, the company launched a patent infringement lawsuit against Apple over their new iPad with LTE and Retina Display. On a second front, Apple has been sued by NovelPoint Security over Intel based Macs allegedly using their technology to thwart viruses. 


The Alleged Patent Infringements In-Part


In ADAPTIX Inc.'s Count One they allege Infringement of US Patent 7,454,212.


2 - apdaptx patent 7,454,212

The formal complaint reads as follows: "On information and belief, Apple is directly and/or indirectly infringing at least one claim of the '212 Patent in this judicial district and elsewhere in Texas and the United States by, among other things, making, using, offering for sale, selling and/or importing computerized devices including without limitation Retina display iPads sold to AT&T which, at a minimum, directly infringe the '212 Patent."  


In Count Two, ADAPTIX claims infringement of US Patent 6,947,748. The complaint is identical to the one presented in Count One above. It should also be noted that the lawsuit includes AT&T for selling the new iPad the LTE.


3 - adaptix patent 6,947,748

The case was filed on March 9, 2012 in the United States Texas Eastern District Court, Tyler Office. The presiding Judge in this case is noted as being Judge Leonard Davis.


It should be noted that ADAPTIX, Inc. was acquired by Acacia Research Corporation in January 2012. According Wikipedia, Acacia Research Corporation has adopted the business model known as patent trolling.


NovelPoint Security Sues Apple


On another front, Apple is being sued by NovelPoint Security LLC. The lawsuit involves patents that include a computer security system covered by one or more claims of patents 5,434,562 and 6,212,635. The computer systems noted in the complaint are Intel based Macs starting in 2006.


4, patent 6,212,636 abstract re NovelPoint Security lawsuit 

Is this another patent troll case? It appears so. The court document reads: "Plaintiff is the owner by assignment of the '562 Patent with sole rights to enforce the '562 Patent and sue infringers." I don't know how you would read that otherwise.


Notice: Patently Apple presents only a brief summary of certain legal cases/ lawsuits which are part of the public record for journalistic news purposes. Readers are cautioned that Patently Apple does not offer an opinion on the merit of the case and strictly presents the allegations made in said legal cases / lawsuits. A lawyer should be consulted for any further details or analysis. About Comments: Patently Apple reserves the right to post, dismiss or edit comments. On most legal cases, comments will be closed. See our Legal Archives for other patent infringement cases.


Here are a Few Sites covering our Original Report

MacSurfer, Twitter, Facebook, Apple Investor News, Google Reader, Macnews, iPhone World Canada, MarketWatch, MacDailyNews, iPadItalia Italy, NU Netherlands, NUZ Netherlands, Radu Georgescu Romania,and more.  






The report clearly states that Adaptix is "recognized in the industry as one of the first developers of cutting edge OFDMA-based mobile wireless systems." Maybe you missed that.

Derek Cuffie

This could NOT be more hilarious:

“The company claims to have conceived . . . that form the foundation of today’s advanced 4G broadband wireless technology and systems"

Seeing as there are ZERO actual 4G devices on the market today, that '4G' continues to ONLY be a deceptive marketing hype term with no actual hardware available to run it:

Did they invent LTE Advanced (LTE-A)? No. That's Qualcom tech. Did they invent 802.16? No, that's an international standard tech. These are the only two upcoming ACTUAL 4G technologies on the horizon.


Marc Driftmeyer

It doesn't matter. This case will result in either a cross-license or ADAPTIX being buried.

They don't have squat on Apple's LTE patent catalog they acquired recently.


Apple sues everyone even for ridiculous patents. Therefore that is good news.


They're going after the one with the most $. If they win, and in my opinion it's another waste of time in court, others will give in, if they come after them at all :/


@ Stephen.

Sometimes the other companies (Samsung etc) pay up as an anoyance fee to save time. Sometimes a company like Adaptix will sue the big dog first and with a victory in hand, they go after the other smaller fry. They line'm up like ducks after that. If you beat Apple, you beat them all.


Why only at apple ? , how come they did sue other company as Motorola and Samsung etc companies . There something I don't understand , why they are accusing only at apple but not to Samsung , Motorla , etc companies about 4G at already in Samsung , Motorla and etc companies so far , but why only Apple they suing , it's crazy at adpatx ,

I really liked Apple products , it's one of the best product at ease of use , touch and see !

The comments to this entry are closed.